Plotter vs Pantser. The Final Countdown (cue Rocky music)! |
Skip to content

Plotter vs Pantser. The Final Countdown (cue Rocky music)!

TuesdayTips Button

For years, I’ve considered myself a slow writer. I can sit at my computer for an hour and knock out three sentences. Even on the days when I manage to write a couple of thousand words, I end up deleting half of them and then rewriting them, and then cutting and pasting them into another section of my manuscript before deleting them again. SIGH.

Tuesday Tips_Plotter vs Pantser1This is like some kind of medieval torture!

My debut novel When the World was Flat (and we were in love) took about five years from conception to publication. In The Beginning There Was Us took about three years. That means my current manuscript should be done by the end of this year. HOPEFULLY.

I’m a monogamous writer – I only dedicate myself to one manuscript at a time – but I have a full-time and relatively demanding day job, which means writing is relegated to after hours (when my brain’s about as effective as mashed potato soaked in gravy) and on weekends (when not hanging out with family and friends or stuck doing chores). Sometimes I feel like just giving up, particularly when I catch up with one of my very talented and extremely prolific author friends who manages to write hundred-thousand words manuscripts in the space of three months (and I’m talking FINAL drafts, as in READY TO SUBMIT to an agent or publisher). GRRR!

Tuesday Tips_Plotter vs Pantser2aI’m happy for you. I really am.

I must have AT LEAST a hundred unfinished manuscripts which will only ever be read by my virus protector on my computer—some a few hundred words (more so ideas than manuscripts) and others a few thousand. I’ve finally come to the realization that in order to finish a manuscript I actually need to plot my stories, instead of writing by the seat of my pants. As a pantser, I end up writing a first chapter and then poking and prodding it like a dead carcass washed up on a beach, before finally rolling it back into the depths of my hard-drive.

 TT_Plotter vs Pantser1aBye. Looking forward to seeing you, like NEVER!

The other benefit to plotting is that it reduces the number of revisions. I must have added at least another TWO YEARS to my drafting of When The World Was Flat (and we were in love) because I kept adding new storylines. This included a COMPLETE CHANGE of the genre after the first draft—from contemporary fiction to science fiction. I do love letting a story evolve organically, but the flip side of that coin is that it would take me about fifty years to have less than a handful of manuscripts finished. If I were writing literary fiction it would be completely justifiable, but I write commercial fiction—as in purely for entertainment—AND I WANT TO PERFORM IN MORE THAN ONE SHOW IN MY LIFETIME.

My current WIP (The Day We Lived Forever) is the first novel I’ve EVER plotted from go to woah. I can literally hold the entire story—scene-by-scene—in the palm of my hand (I use palm cards). I’m anticipating a first draft in two months of ad-hoc writing (am currently halfway through). If I were writing full-time, I could realistically say I would have a first draft in a couple of weeks.

SO, we come to the moral of the story—if you’re a pantser who’s struggling to finish a manuscript, I can HIGHLY recommend you try plotting. We all know the problem with plotting is it can be so BORING, BUT if you look at it as a chance to legitimately stare out of the window or lay down on the couch and call it work, it suddenly sounds much more exciting—at least to a daydreamer like me (stay tuned for another post on the actual process of plotting).

TT_Plotter vs Pantser3This is how everyone works. Right?

Ernest Hemmingway famously (and arguably) said that writing was like cutting open a vein and bleeding onto a page. Sheesh. I shudder to think what he would have said about getting published! Every Tuesday, I dust off my creative writing degree (yes, from an actual, real-life university) and share my learnings about the process of writing and getting published (yes, I know learnings is technically not a word, but I worked in public relations for a number of years and we like to make words up. Helifordite?). You can check out all of my Tuesday Tips here.

2015/06/plotter-vs-pantser-the-final-countdown-cue-rocky-music/&send=false&layout=button_count&width=450&show_faces=false&action=like&colorscheme=light&font&height=21" scrolling="no" frameborder="0" style="border:none; overflow:hidden; width:450px; height:21px;" allowtransparency="true">
5 Comments Post a comment
  1. Melody Brocke #

    Hi, Ingrid :) I’ve been browsing your blog, and I must say, it looks pretty awesome—I love that air of comedy mixed with seriousness that you have in your writing. I was just wondering, is there anyway to subscribe by email? :) (Sorry, but I’m not seeing any subscribe widgets. I might just be blind though, hehe.)
    All the best,

    June 14, 2015
  2. Ingrid Jonach #

    Thanks so much for getting in touch, Melody. And for your kind words about my posts! You’ve prompted me to do something I’ve been putting off – learn how to use MailChimp. Haha! There’s now a (not-so) sparkly, brand-spanking-new subscribe option in the right sidebar.

    I hope you enjoy my future posts.

    Thanks x

    June 14, 2015
  3. Walt Socha #

    Ditto on your experience.

    I started out pantsing my first book…and got lost quick.

    My second one was pseudo-plotted: detailed for initial chapters, getting more general in later. As the earlier parts became fleshed out, I expanded the outline of the later. Seems to work.

    My editor had some concerns about the middle of my first book (hopefully out this fall). Was baffled on how to approach re-plotting a existing work. But then I “discovered” Scrivener…its “corkboard” view is great for plotting.

    Definitely a plotter now-a-days.

    PS…nice animated gifs..
    PPS…we have two cats: Schitz and Zoid…

    July 5, 2015
    • Ingrid Jonach #

      We sound very similar, Walt! And I love your cat’s names—very interesting when put together! Good luck with the revisions on your first book!

      July 5, 2015

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. The nearly ALWAYS occasionally BORING task of plotting a story |

Leave a comment to Ingrid Jonach Cancel reply

You may use basic HTML in your comments. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS